Diane Ravitch may be adamant and forceful... but hysterical? In a post today, she refers to another, one by Gary Houchens, a professor of "Educational, Leadership, & Research" at Western Kentucky University. His is entitled "Biometric hysteria: the anti-research mentality of the educational status quo." In a postscript Ravitch writes: I do not like to … Continue reading Biometric "Hysteria"?
Often, when people wonder if American higher education might follow the fate of journalism, falling victim to inability to adapt to new technological milieux, they are thinking in terms of money and its impact. The financial structures of protected and centralized institutions can collapse when product becomes cheaply and widely available, both for creation and … Continue reading “Objectivity” As a Barrier to Education: Teaching Intellectual Responsibility and the Role of the Citizen
Standardized testing is based on a number of assumptions, including that knowledge can be broken down into identifiable bits of absolute, unchanging information—and that education is mastery of such bits. This is nonsense, of course, and has been understood to be nonsense for eons. As Paulo Freire writes, it is an ‘imprisoning of reality,’ pretending … Continue reading Testing Can Never Suffice (How Many Times Must We Say It?)
In a speech last week, Diane Ravitch said:The philanthropists and Wall Street hedge fund managers and Republicans and the Obama administration and assorted rightwing billionaires have some ideas about how to change American education. They aren’t teachers but they think they know how to fix the schools. Their ideas boil down to this strategy: NCLB … Continue reading Skinner, Freire… and Ravitch
The last passages of Paulo Freire’s Pedagogy of the Oppressed and B. F. Skinner’s The Technology of Teaching are particularly instructive to those of us exploring ways of improving education today, though they were each writing over forty years ago. Though their approaches are different, they both recognize, with John Dewey and so many others, … Continue reading Freire and Skinner, Once Again
Both Paulo Freire, in Pedagogy of the Oppressed, and B. F. Skinner, in The Technology of Learning, imbue their texts with the language of particular ideologies, but one can dig through the cant and find real substance. Again, as I have said, though Freire focuses on the system of education and Skinner on the method, … Continue reading Freire and Skinner: A Third Time
It always amazes me how our new discussions are almost always repeats of older ones. Even this, of course, is an old topic—I’ve even heard people argue that almost any topic we might contest today can be found in Plato. Me, I generally don’t go back that far in my search for prior argument: the … Continue reading Skinner and Freire, Continued